. Neutering (especially of female dogs) is a major surgery that is routine in the UK. Since neutering reduces the amount of testosterone, the hormonal changes can put the pet at risk for obesity. Males are castrated whereby the testicles are surgically removed. In a nation such as America, that is cramming stray and unwanted dogs into every available rescue/shelter, and then euthanizing millions more each year, Norway's law might make you gasp, or even throw a tantrum! It is considered cruel and detrimental to the dog's health and well-being. Over here in Germany the common practice is to spay neuter male dogs at around 1 year and . Although spaying and neutering dogs is commonplace in the US, it is illegal to do so in Norway except for medical reasons. until 1988 the operation was illegal unless there was a medical reason for it. Releasing agencies (animal shelters, control agencies, etc.) The UC Davis study bucks what it calls "the frequently mentioned advantages of early neutering of female dogs" as "protection" against mammary cancer and the consensus embrace of the research. Because the bone growth plates may close earlier in dogs neutered young, orthopaedic problems such as hip dysplasia and cranial cruciate ligament tears may result. Finally, while smaller dogs should be spay/neutered at . Under Norway's Animal Welfare Act, it is illegal to neuter your dog in Norway unless it was deemed medically necessary or for animal welfare reasons. Britain has one of the highest neutering rates [] The link between obesity and spaying or neutering has to do with hormones. Dogs with a high level of training and controlled life can be left intact without contributing to the populat. In Norway it is actually illegal to spay or neuter your dog. - Source In fact, in some European Union countries where gonadectomy is illegal unless deemed medically necessary (such as Norway) there are no significant problems with pet overpopulation, indicating that the pet overpopulation problem that exists in the United States is due to cultural differences on the importance of pets, the responsibility of pet . In Sweden, 93% of females and 99% of male dogs are left intact. On the basis that humans shouldn't have the right to alter a dog to the benefit of the human, a dog's life should be to the benefit of the dog. Some first-world countries view desexing to be inhumane In some countries, spaying and neutering are considered to be inhumane and is even illegal. She mentioned that it is illegal to spay/neuter a dog in Norway. Norway is the first country to introduce compulsory paternity leave. In Norway, it is illegal to spay or neuter a dog without a valid medical reason. Removing a dog's testicles or ovaries. In Norway, where spaying dogs is illegal (it's regarded as a "mutilation"), over 50% of female dogs suffer from malignant mammary cancer. W-w-w-w-haaaat?! But you'd know that if you bothered to read all the way through the links you posted, rather than just cherry-picking points that support your opinion. The comment about it being illegal to spay or neuter a dog in Norway caused me to wonder about the prevalence of strays in that country as well as the rest of Europe. Norwegians believe spaying or neutering a dog is cruel Norwegians believe it is cruel to spay or neuter dogs. Releasing agencies (animal shelters, control agencies, etc.) About 85% of dogs in the US have been neutered. In 2020, only 29% of the UK dog owning population reported their dog had not been neutered (PDSA PAW Report, 2020). Answer (1 of 2): With very limited experience, I lean toward thinking that many European dogs are trained to a much higher level than many American pets in otherwise equivalent families. It is important to monitor a neutered dog's diet at least for a couple of years to prevent weight gain. Cats and dogs are only sold from individual breeders, even if it is not illegal to sell them from pet shops. Indeed, responsible pet ownership is now equated with having your companion animal's testicles or ovaries removed, and in some communities it is illegal to allow a dog to reproduce without a special permit. Contrast this with most of Europe who finds this practice barbaric. Danai Christopoulou. With these opposing philosophies, veterinarians in the US have begun . When comparing pet dog ownership in Denmark and Australia, then it is striking how much public attitudes to spay & neuter differ. Where's the dogs' well-being in dog breeding and neutering? Recent studies have shown that early neutered dogs have a significantly higher risk of developing other cancers and joint diseases that are more difficult to treat than testicular or mammary cancer. It's not just the Scandinavian countries that aren't so brainwashed into the pro spay/neuter dogma. Here are some of the ways spaying/neutering effects our pets health. In 2020, only 29% of the UK dog owning population reported their dog had not been neutered (PDSA PAW Report, 2020). Around 80% of pet cats in the US have been spayed or neutered. Britain has one of the highest neutering rates [] With neutering and and spaying your animal might face and entirely different fate as a result . Mean age of death of sterilized dogs: 9.4 years. Knvelsrud thinks one reason why Norway have different legislation than the USA is that we don't face the same challenges. We had our dog spayed just after her first oestrus. Under Norway's Animal Welfare Act, it is illegal to neuter your dog unless deemed medically necessary or for their welfare, which is quite different from here in the UK where neutering is common . 31 July 2018. And, surprisingly, the results of these studies seem to suggest the opposite of what people commonly assume. 1/4 of all female dogs in Norway develop mammary cancer, and there is a lot more dog-on-dog aggression than there is in countries where spay/neuter is the norm. If I have an un-neutered German Shepherd, Rottie, whatever, I'm going to get nasty looks at the dog park and may not even be allowed inside. #2. They produce hormones for the dogs body, which is how his organs communicate with one another. 15. This is very different to the approach taken in many other countries - in Norway, for instance, the Norwegian Animal Welfare Act makes it illegal In my experience some unconfident neutered dogs find . #3. The law was amended and relaxed a bit in 2010, but it is still in effect. - Source. Norwegians also believe that it is unethical to neuter a dog for behaviour reasons. The likelihood of developing this common cancer in many breeds after neutering rises by a factor of 1.6 and has a very poor prognosis. The goal is to decrease the number of unwanted animals that suffer and die on the streets, decrease the risk to public health and safety, and . 1). #5: Neutering male dogs increases the risk of cardiac hemangiosarcoma. Only 7 percent of female dogs in Sweden are spayed. Increased life expectancy in sterilized male dogs: 13.8%. Neutered dogs have lower calorie needs because of the alteration of hormones. . Neutered dogs . This might sound surprising at first, but . [xxxviii] However, keeping turtles is usually accepted on special permission. In the USA over 90 percent of male dogs are neutered, and in many cities and towns owners can be fined or their pets denied access to dog parks if the dogs haven't had the procedure. Norway). One which would allow owners to neuter dogs who showed sexual aggression, or whose lifestyle is negatively affected by being not being spayed or neutered. There have actually been quite a few studies done on the effects of spaying and neutering dogs. Interestingly enough, it's illegal to spay or neuter dogs in Norway. In certain countries it is even illegal unless there is a medical reason. Some are spayed and neutered as young as eight weeks. If I have an un-neutered German Shepherd, Rottie, whatever, I'm going to get nasty looks at the dog park and may not even be allowed inside. List of Cons of Dog Neutering. . (2009) found that neutering female Rottweilers before four years of age reduces life expectancy by 30%. until 1988 the operation was illegal unless there was a medical reason for it. Not an answer for behaviour problems. In fact, in Norway, it is illegal to neuter your dog unless it was deemed a medical necessity. Spay and neuter everything . For example, in Norway, it's illegal to neuter a pet unless there is a valid medical reason. . . Female dog neutering or 'spaying' a female animal involves removing the womb and ovaries (an ovaro-hysterectomy). . Didn't find Norway, but thought the Dutch paper was interesting. Where do you have you information from that it is against the law to spay or neuter dogs in Norway? Females that kept their ovaries the longest were nine times more likely to achieve exceptional longevity (13+ years). Granted, most of them stem from the need to protect the health and freedom of its citizens, as well as to . Norway always ranks close to the top of "Best Places to Live" lists, and depending on your point of view, it might seem like heaven for dogs. She explained to me that most people use neutering to "correct" behaviors. are required in approximately 32 states to provide for the sterilization of all dogs or cats they transfer or adopt out. Neutering is perceived as unnecessary in both Denmark and Norway . In Norway, desexing is illegal except in extenuating medical circumstances. Under Norway's Animal Welfare Act , it is illegal to neuter your dog in Norway unless it was deemed medically necessary or for animal welfare reasons. In Norway, for example, where it is illegal to neuter a dog unless it is deemed medically necessary, the incidence is 53.3%, according to a 2001 study. Some first-world countries view desexing to be inhumane In some countries, spaying and neutering are considered to be inhumane and is even illegal. Exotic animals Reptiles, including turtles, are forbidden to import, sell and keep as pets in Norway. Italy isn't to brainwashed into this dogma either. 1. Norway has taken a slightly different approach. It is absolutely legal. In Sweden, castration was made exempt from the prohibition to remove body parts in 1988, hence neutering is allowed under the Swedish Animal Protection Act [djurskyddslagen (1988:534) 10/11] and its regulations 1988:539. The average cat spay cost in the US can go up . Endocrine disease. In female Golden . In America, where neutering is a matter of owner choice, the proportion of neutered males is 64% - but this includes rescue dogs who were neutered as a matter of routine before being rehomed. Stine Christiansen . (2010) A majority of states have implemented mandatory spay and neuter laws to address the overpopulation of homeless animals. . Under Norway's Animal Welfare Act, it is illegal to neuter your dog in Norway unless it was deemed medically necessary or for animal welfare reasons. In some countries, spaying and neutering are considered to be inhumane and is even illegal. For example in Norway, neutering dogs is illegal unless a veterinarian deems it medically necessary. . . Apr 22, 2013. Compared to the US many European countries don't nearly the number of stray animals even though they don't de-sex nearly as many dogs and cats (Sweden, Norway). The lead author of the study notes: The rationale is that it is morally wrong to surgically alter a dog for human whim or convenience, which puts spay/neuter on a par with ear cropping and tail docking. Although surgical neutering is considered part of responsible pet ownership in the UK (similar to vaccinations) and performed routinely across the country, in Germany and Scandinavia, for example, surgical neutering is considered "mutilation" and is prohibited by law. A majority of states have implemented mandatory spay and neuter laws to address the overpopulation of homeless animals.